What it can and can't do
No fraud tool stops all fraud, and any tool that stops fraud sometimes stops a real customer. Here is where FraudToad stands.
What it's for
Card testing: bursts of small orders that check stolen cards. It looks at the pattern across orders (one card on many accounts, many cards from one IP, a store-wide surge of tiny orders) rather than judging each order alone, because a card test often looks low-risk on its own.
It acts before payment is taken. With manual capture, a fraudulent order is voided rather than refunded: no settled sale, no chargeback, and no mark against your store's fraud ratios with the card networks. Chargeback tools work after a sale settles; FraudToad is complementary to them. Stop it before it settles, and use a chargeback tool for what gets through.
What it can miss
- One-off fraud. A single order with a stolen card, placed carefully, looks like a real customer. Shopify's own risk analysis (rule E7) is the main signal for those.
- Slow testing. A tester who uses one card very slowly can get a first cheap order through before the card shows up on enough accounts.
- Automatic capture. If payment is taken at checkout, there is nothing to void: the app only holds flagged orders for you, and refunding one from Shopify loses the card fees.
- Orders older than the app. It only sees orders placed after it was installed, apart from the read-only test on past orders.
When it gets a real customer wrong
- Start in shadow mode, where nothing is held or cancelled, and switch to enforce when what it flags looks right.
- Most real customers who trip a rule are held, not cancelled: one signal alone rarely reaches the cancel threshold. A held order loses nothing; approve it and it ships.
- Repeat customers in good standing are allowlisted automatically and never cancelled.
- Every decision lists the rules that fired, so you can see why and loosen the rule in Settings.
- If a real order was cancelled, the customer's card was only authorized, not charged, and they can order again once you remove them from the blocklist.
Support
Email support@fraudtoad.com. Include your store's address (yourstore.myshopify.com) and the order number if it's about an order.